Compare Undercounter Ice Makers

Closely matched undercounter ice makers side by side, 104 pairs in all. Each pair is scored the same way, with the independent tests and specs that separate them. See the full ranking.

Compare any two

FirstChoose a product…Avallon AIMG151PSSO Outdoor – $2,199EdgeStar IB450SSP – $1,489GE Profile UCC15NJII Clear Ice – $1,761.50GE Profile UCC15NPRII Clear Ice – $3,059GE Profile UNC15NPWII Nugget – $3,593.10Hoshizaki AM-50BAK – $3,100Hoshizaki C-80BAK – $4,610KoolMore KM-BIM66-NSS Nugget – $1,499Marvel MLCP215 Clear Ice – $4,279Marvel MOCP215 Outdoor Clear Ice – $5,029Marvel MRNP215 Nugget Ice – $5,089Marvel Professional MPCP415 – $3,999Perlick HP15CI Clear Ice – $5,510Scotsman Brilliance SRC065 – $4,499Scotsman Brilliance SRN110 – $5,999Scotsman CU50PAX Gourmet Cube – $3,657Sub-Zero DEU1550I – $5,430Sub-Zero DEU1550IP with Pump – $6,285Sub-Zero UC-15I – $3,710Summit BIM44GADA – $1,890.02Summit BIM47OSADA Outdoor – $2,191.26Summit BIM63OSADA Outdoor – $2,095.64True Residential TUI-15 Clear Ice – $5,719U-Line HCP115 Clear Ice – $4,149U-Line ONP115 Outdoor Nugget Ice – $5,239U-Line RNP115 Nugget Ice – $4,849VEVOR HBZB-36F 80 lb – $714.99Viking FIUI5152D Clear Ice – $3,939Viking Professional FPIM5151 – $5,499Viking Professional FPNI515 Nugget – $6,399Whynter UIM-502SS – $1,099.99Zephyr Presrv Clear Ice PRCG15P0AP – $3,299Manitowoc NEO UDP0080A – $2,660Manitowoc NEO UDP0140A – $2,780Newair 18 in Clear Ice NCI065SSC0 – $1,929.99Summit BIM182 – $2,204.18Summit BIM182OS Outdoor – $2,206.51vsSecondChoose a product…Avallon AIMG151PSSO Outdoor – $2,199EdgeStar IB450SSP – $1,489GE Profile UCC15NJII Clear Ice – $1,761.50GE Profile UCC15NPRII Clear Ice – $3,059GE Profile UNC15NPWII Nugget – $3,593.10Hoshizaki AM-50BAK – $3,100Hoshizaki C-80BAK – $4,610KoolMore KM-BIM66-NSS Nugget – $1,499Marvel MLCP215 Clear Ice – $4,279Marvel MOCP215 Outdoor Clear Ice – $5,029Marvel MRNP215 Nugget Ice – $5,089Marvel Professional MPCP415 – $3,999Perlick HP15CI Clear Ice – $5,510Scotsman Brilliance SRC065 – $4,499Scotsman Brilliance SRN110 – $5,999Scotsman CU50PAX Gourmet Cube – $3,657Sub-Zero DEU1550I – $5,430Sub-Zero DEU1550IP with Pump – $6,285Sub-Zero UC-15I – $3,710Summit BIM44GADA – $1,890.02Summit BIM47OSADA Outdoor – $2,191.26Summit BIM63OSADA Outdoor – $2,095.64True Residential TUI-15 Clear Ice – $5,719U-Line HCP115 Clear Ice – $4,149U-Line ONP115 Outdoor Nugget Ice – $5,239U-Line RNP115 Nugget Ice – $4,849VEVOR HBZB-36F 80 lb – $714.99Viking FIUI5152D Clear Ice – $3,939Viking Professional FPIM5151 – $5,499Viking Professional FPNI515 Nugget – $6,399Whynter UIM-502SS – $1,099.99Zephyr Presrv Clear Ice PRCG15P0AP – $3,299Manitowoc NEO UDP0080A – $2,660Manitowoc NEO UDP0140A – $2,780Newair 18 in Clear Ice NCI065SSC0 – $1,929.99Summit BIM182 – $2,204.18Summit BIM182OS Outdoor – $2,206.51Compare

The picker needs JavaScript. Each listed comparison has its own page.

• 15 in wide 79
• 18 in and wider 10
• Across widths 15

Best 15 Inch Undercounter Ice Makers

• True Residential TUI-15 Clear Ice vs VEVOR HBZB-36F 80 lb
• Scotsman Brilliance SRN110 vs VEVOR HBZB-36F 80 lb
• Scotsman Brilliance SRN110 vs True Residential TUI-15 Clear Ice
• True Residential TUI-15 Clear Ice vs Zephyr Presrv Clear Ice PRCG15P0AP
• VEVOR HBZB-36F 80 lb vs Whynter UIM-502SS
• True Residential TUI-15 Clear Ice vs Whynter UIM-502SS
• VEVOR HBZB-36F 80 lb vs Viking Professional FPNI515 Nugget
• KoolMore KM-BIM66-NSS Nugget vs Zephyr Presrv Clear Ice PRCG15P0AP
• KoolMore KM-BIM66-NSS Nugget vs Summit BIM63OSADA Outdoor
• Scotsman Brilliance SRN110 vs Whynter UIM-502SS
• Summit BIM63OSADA Outdoor vs Zephyr Presrv Clear Ice PRCG15P0AP
• Scotsman Brilliance SRN110 vs Viking Professional FPNI515 Nugget
• KoolMore KM-BIM66-NSS Nugget vs U-Line ONP115 Outdoor Nugget Ice
• Viking Professional FPNI515 Nugget vs Whynter UIM-502SS
• KoolMore KM-BIM66-NSS Nugget vs U-Line RNP115 Nugget Ice
• KoolMore KM-BIM66-NSS Nugget vs Viking Professional FPIM5151
• Summit BIM63OSADA Outdoor vs U-Line ONP115 Outdoor Nugget Ice
• Viking Professional FPIM5151 vs Viking Professional FPNI515 Nugget
• U-Line ONP115 Outdoor Nugget Ice vs U-Line RNP115 Nugget Ice
• U-Line ONP115 Outdoor Nugget Ice vs Viking Professional FPIM5151
• U-Line RNP115 Nugget Ice vs Viking Professional FPIM5151
• Marvel MRNP215 Nugget Ice vs U-Line ONP115 Outdoor Nugget Ice
• Marvel MRNP215 Nugget Ice vs U-Line RNP115 Nugget Ice
• Marvel MRNP215 Nugget Ice vs Viking Professional FPIM5151
• U-Line HCP115 Clear Ice vs U-Line ONP115 Outdoor Nugget Ice
• Sub-Zero DEU1550IP with Pump vs U-Line ONP115 Outdoor Nugget Ice
• Sub-Zero DEU1550IP with Pump vs U-Line RNP115 Nugget Ice
• Sub-Zero DEU1550IP with Pump vs Viking Professional FPIM5151
• Marvel Professional MPCP415 vs Summit BIM44GADA
• Summit BIM44GADA vs Summit BIM47OSADA Outdoor
• Avallon AIMG151PSSO Outdoor vs Summit BIM44GADA
• Sub-Zero DEU1550I vs U-Line ONP115 Outdoor Nugget Ice
• Hoshizaki C-80BAK vs U-Line ONP115 Outdoor Nugget Ice
• Sub-Zero DEU1550I vs U-Line RNP115 Nugget Ice
• Sub-Zero DEU1550I vs Viking Professional FPIM5151
• Hoshizaki C-80BAK vs U-Line RNP115 Nugget Ice
• Hoshizaki C-80BAK vs Viking Professional FPIM5151
• EdgeStar IB450SSP vs U-Line HCP115 Clear Ice
• Avallon AIMG151PSSO Outdoor vs Summit BIM47OSADA Outdoor
• GE Profile UCC15NJII Clear Ice vs Summit BIM44GADA
• Marvel Professional MPCP415 vs Viking FIUI5152D Clear Ice
• GE Profile UCC15NJII Clear Ice vs Summit BIM47OSADA Outdoor
• Sub-Zero DEU1550I vs Sub-Zero DEU1550IP with Pump
• Avallon AIMG151PSSO Outdoor vs GE Profile UCC15NJII Clear Ice
• EdgeStar IB450SSP vs GE Profile UCC15NJII Clear Ice
• Sub-Zero UC-15I vs U-Line HCP115 Clear Ice
• EdgeStar IB450SSP vs Sub-Zero UC-15I
• GE Profile UCC15NPRII Clear Ice vs Summit BIM44GADA
• EdgeStar IB450SSP vs Scotsman Brilliance SRC065
• Marvel MLCP215 Clear Ice vs Summit BIM44GADA
• GE Profile UCC15NPRII Clear Ice vs Summit BIM47OSADA Outdoor
• Sub-Zero DEU1550I vs Sub-Zero UC-15I
• Perlick HP15CI Clear Ice vs U-Line HCP115 Clear Ice
• GE Profile UCC15NJII Clear Ice vs Scotsman Brilliance SRC065
• EdgeStar IB450SSP vs GE Profile UCC15NPRII Clear Ice
• Marvel MOCP215 Outdoor Clear Ice vs Summit BIM44GADA
• EdgeStar IB450SSP vs Perlick HP15CI Clear Ice
• GE Profile UCC15NJII Clear Ice vs GE Profile UCC15NPRII Clear Ice
• EdgeStar IB450SSP vs Scotsman CU50PAX Gourmet Cube
• Marvel MOCP215 Outdoor Clear Ice vs Marvel Professional MPCP415
• EdgeStar IB450SSP vs GE Profile UNC15NPWII Nugget
• Hoshizaki AM-50BAK vs Marvel Professional MPCP415
• Scotsman Brilliance SRC065 vs Sub-Zero UC-15I
• GE Profile UCC15NJII Clear Ice vs Scotsman CU50PAX Gourmet Cube
• Marvel MLCP215 Clear Ice vs Viking FIUI5152D Clear Ice
• Marvel MOCP215 Outdoor Clear Ice vs Viking FIUI5152D Clear Ice
• Hoshizaki AM-50BAK vs Viking FIUI5152D Clear Ice
• Perlick HP15CI Clear Ice vs Sub-Zero UC-15I
• Scotsman CU50PAX Gourmet Cube vs Sub-Zero UC-15I
• GE Profile UCC15NPRII Clear Ice vs Scotsman Brilliance SRC065
• Perlick HP15CI Clear Ice vs Scotsman Brilliance SRC065
• Scotsman CU50PAX Gourmet Cube vs Scotsman Brilliance SRC065
• GE Profile UNC15NPWII Nugget vs Scotsman Brilliance SRC065
• GE Profile UCC15NPRII Clear Ice vs Scotsman CU50PAX Gourmet Cube
• GE Profile UCC15NPRII Clear Ice vs GE Profile UNC15NPWII Nugget
• GE Profile UNC15NPWII Nugget vs Scotsman CU50PAX Gourmet Cube
• Marvel MLCP215 Clear Ice vs Marvel MOCP215 Outdoor Clear Ice
• Hoshizaki AM-50BAK vs Marvel MLCP215 Clear Ice
• Hoshizaki AM-50BAK vs Marvel MOCP215 Outdoor Clear Ice

Best 18 and 24 Inch Undercounter Ice Makers

• Manitowoc NEO UDP0080A vs Manitowoc NEO UDP0140A
• Manitowoc NEO UDP0140A vs Newair 18 in Clear Ice NCI065SSC0
• Manitowoc NEO UDP0140A vs Summit BIM182
• Manitowoc NEO UDP0140A vs Summit BIM182OS Outdoor
• Manitowoc NEO UDP0080A vs Newair 18 in Clear Ice NCI065SSC0
• Manitowoc NEO UDP0080A vs Summit BIM182
• Manitowoc NEO UDP0080A vs Summit BIM182OS Outdoor
• Newair 18 in Clear Ice NCI065SSC0 vs Summit BIM182
• Newair 18 in Clear Ice NCI065SSC0 vs Summit BIM182OS Outdoor
• Summit BIM182 vs Summit BIM182OS Outdoor

Across widths

• Manitowoc NEO UDP0140A vs VEVOR HBZB-36F 80 lb
• Manitowoc NEO UDP0140A vs Scotsman Brilliance SRN110
• Manitowoc NEO UDP0140A vs Whynter UIM-502SS
• Manitowoc NEO UDP0080A vs VEVOR HBZB-36F 80 lb
• Manitowoc NEO UDP0080A vs True Residential TUI-15 Clear Ice
• Manitowoc NEO UDP0080A vs Scotsman Brilliance SRN110
• Summit BIM182OS Outdoor vs Summit BIM63OSADA Outdoor
• Newair 18 in Clear Ice NCI065SSC0 vs U-Line ONP115 Outdoor Nugget Ice
• Summit BIM182 vs U-Line ONP115 Outdoor Nugget Ice
• Summit BIM182OS Outdoor vs U-Line ONP115 Outdoor Nugget Ice
• Summit BIM182 vs U-Line RNP115 Nugget Ice
• Summit BIM182OS Outdoor vs U-Line RNP115 Nugget Ice
• Summit BIM182 vs U-Line HCP115 Clear Ice
• Summit BIM182OS Outdoor vs U-Line HCP115 Clear Ice
• Summit BIM182 vs Summit BIM47OSADA Outdoor