CURT 18110 Steel Tray Carrier vs MaxxHaul 50149 Folding Aluminum Carrier

Last updated: October 31, 2026

The MaxxHaul 50149 Folding Aluminum Carrier is the better carrier overall, rated 4.0 to 3.1. The MaxxHaul 50149 Folding Aluminum Carrier leads on features, capacity and value. The CURT 18110 Steel Tray Carrier wins on warranty. The CURT 18110 Steel Tray Carrier costs $22.01 less ($126.98 vs $148.99).

CURT 18110 Steel Tray Carrier vs MaxxHaul 50149 Folding Aluminum Carrier

Prices were last checked October 31, 2026 and are subject to change; the price and availability shown by the retailer at the time of purchase apply.

Which should you buy?

Scores side by side

Each factor is scored 0-100 against the same fixed reference points for every hitch carriers carrier; a clear win is highlighted. How we rank explains each one.

Factor weightMaxxHaul 50149 Folding Aluminum CarrierCURT 18110 Steel Tray Carrier
Overall rating4.0/53.1/5
Value 30%100 $29.80 per 100 lb of rated load ($148.99, 500 lb)79 $42.33 per 100 lb of rated load ($126.98, 300 lb)
Capacity 20%67 500 lb load rating0 300 lb load rating
Weight 15%95 weighs 32.7 lb50 weight not published (neutral score used)
Features 20%68 folds up0 none of the scored features
Warranty 15%0 0.2-year warranty100 limited lifetime warranty

Specifications

MaxxHaul 50149 Folding Aluminum CarrierCURT 18110 Steel Tray Carrier
Capacity
TypeHitch basket or platformHitch basket or platform
Load rating500 lb300 lb
Cargo area50 x 22 x 5 in48 x 20 x 2.8 in
Build
Weight32.7 lb-
MaterialAluminumSteel
Finish-powder coat
Fits receiver2 in1.25 or 2 in
Features
Folds upYesNo
Tilts for hatch access-No
Anti-rattle-No
Net or straps included-No
Warranty0.2 yearsLimited lifetime

All carrier comparisons →