Liberty Pumps Sump Pumps Ranked

Last updated: October 31, 2026

5 Liberty Pumps sump pumps ranked. Each one is scored and ranked against every brand in its size, so "#3 mid-size" means third of all mid-size sump pumps here, not third among Liberty Pumps's own.

Liberty Pumps makes 5 current sump pumps: 3 up to 1/3 HP and 2 1/2 HP and up. Prices run from $165 for the Liberty Pumps S37 to $323.25 for the Liberty Pumps 287. Its best-rated model in each size: the Liberty Pumps 257 (#8 of 16 up to 1/3 HP, rated 3.1) and the Liberty Pumps 287 (#13 of 17 1/2 HP and up, rated 2.9).

Prices were last checked October 31, 2026 and are subject to change; the price and availability shown by the retailer at the time of purchase apply.

Liberty Pumps sump pumps 5

  1. Liberty Pumps 257
    #8 up to 1/3 HP3.1Full review

    For a typical basement where a long lasting cast iron pump with a reliable float matters more than raw flow.

    Amazon $216.29
    $216.29
    1/3 HP2,220 GPHVertical float
  2. Liberty Pumps S37
    #12 up to 1/3 HP3.0Full review

    For a newer house or a gritty pit where a low cost Liberty pump that resists debris jams is enough.

    Amazon $165
    $165
    1/3 HP2,100 GPHVertical float
  3. Liberty Pumps 287
    #13 1/2 HP and up2.9Full review

    For a deep basement or a pit that fills fast, where a strong cast iron pump that fits a narrow pit is worth paying for.

    Amazon $323.25
    $323.25
    1/2 HP3,300 GPHVertical float
  4. Liberty Pumps 237
    #15 up to 1/3 HP2.5Full review

    For a narrow or shallow pit with modest inflow, where a light, compact Liberty pump with a magnetic float is enough.

    Amazon $188.95
    $188.95
    1/3 HP1,800 GPHVertical float
  5. Liberty Pumps 457
    #17 1/2 HP and up2.4Full review

    For a narrow pit that needs more lift than a 1/3 HP pump, where a light pump with a magnetic float is preferred over cast iron.

    Amazon $243.05
    $243.05
    1/2 HP2,640 GPHVertical float

Every sump pump ranked