Legacy 5-Gallon Stackable Water Tanks, 4-Pack vs Saratoga Farms 5-Gallon Stackable Containers, 20 Gallons

Last updated: November 9, 2026

The Legacy 5-Gallon Stackable Water Tanks, 4-Pack is the better water storage tank overall, rated 2.9 to 2.7. The Legacy 5-Gallon Stackable Water Tanks, 4-Pack leads on features. The Saratoga Farms 5-Gallon Stackable Containers, 20 Gallons costs $7.02 less ($119.98 vs $127).

Prices were last checked November 9, 2026. Product prices and availability are accurate as of that date and are subject to change; the price and availability shown on Amazon or the retailer's site at the time of purchase apply. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Legacy 5-Gallon Stackable Water Tanks, 4-Pack vs Saratoga Farms 5-Gallon Stackable Containers, 20 Gallons

Which should you buy?

Scores side by side

Each factor is scored 0-100 against the same fixed reference points for every under 25 gallons water storage tank; a clear win is highlighted. How we rank explains each one.

Factor weightLegacy 5-Gallon Stackable Water Tanks, 4-PackSaratoga Farms 5-Gallon Stackable Containers, 20 Gallons
Overall rating2.9/52.7/5
Value 40%36 $6.35 per gallon ($127, 20 gal)39 $6 per gallon ($119.98, 20 gal)
Potable claims 25%50 food-grade, BPA free50 food-grade, BPA free
Features 20%65 spigot included, stackable30 stackable
Warranty 15%0 warranty not published, scored as none0 warranty not published, scored as none

Specifications

Legacy 5-Gallon Stackable Water Tanks, 4-PackSaratoga Farms 5-Gallon Stackable Containers, 20 Gallons
Capacity
Total capacity20 gal20 gal
Containers4 containers4 containers
Size (each)12 x 10 x 15 in-
Water safety
MaterialPlasticHDPE
Food gradeYesYes
BPA freeYesYes
Features
Spigot or outletIncludedNone
StackableYesYes
Made in USA-Yes

All water storage tank comparisons →