Compare Gas Pool Heaters

Closely matched gas pool heaters side by side, 80 pairs in all. Each pair is scored the same way, with the independent tests and specs that separate them. See the full ranking.

Compare any two

FirstChoose a product…Hayward H-Series H135FD – $2,399Hayward H-Series H150FD – $2,999Hayward H-Series H200FD – $3,699Pentair MasterTemp 125 – $2,098Pentair MasterTemp 200 – $3,549Raypak 106A – $2,119Raypak 156A – $1,949Raypak Digital 206A – $3,023Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 200 – $3,650Hayward H-Series H250FD – $3,999Hayward H-Series H400FD – $5,099Jandy JXi 260 – $4,493.12Jandy JXi 400 – $5,300Jandy JXiQ 400 with VersaFlo – $4,991.71Pentair MasterTemp 250 – $3,098Pentair MasterTemp 300 – $4,099.99Pentair MasterTemp 400 – $4,079Raypak AVIA 264A – $3,493Raypak AVIA 404A – $4,426Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 264A – $4,007Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 404A – $4,923Raypak Digital 266A – $3,249Raypak Digital 336A – $3,615Raypak Digital 406A – $3,984Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 400 – $4,499vsSecondChoose a product…Hayward H-Series H135FD – $2,399Hayward H-Series H150FD – $2,999Hayward H-Series H200FD – $3,699Pentair MasterTemp 125 – $2,098Pentair MasterTemp 200 – $3,549Raypak 106A – $2,119Raypak 156A – $1,949Raypak Digital 206A – $3,023Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 200 – $3,650Hayward H-Series H250FD – $3,999Hayward H-Series H400FD – $5,099Jandy JXi 260 – $4,493.12Jandy JXi 400 – $5,300Jandy JXiQ 400 with VersaFlo – $4,991.71Pentair MasterTemp 250 – $3,098Pentair MasterTemp 300 – $4,099.99Pentair MasterTemp 400 – $4,079Raypak AVIA 264A – $3,493Raypak AVIA 404A – $4,426Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 264A – $4,007Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 404A – $4,923Raypak Digital 266A – $3,249Raypak Digital 336A – $3,615Raypak Digital 406A – $3,984Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 400 – $4,499Compare

The picker needs JavaScript. Each listed comparison has its own page.

• Under 250,000 BTU 21
• 250,000 BTU and up 50
• Across sizes 9

Best Small Gas Pool Heaters (Under 250,000 BTU)

• Raypak 156A vs Raypak Digital 206A
• Pentair MasterTemp 200 vs Raypak Digital 206A
• Raypak Digital 206A vs Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 200
• Hayward H-Series H200FD vs Raypak Digital 206A
• Raypak 156A vs Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 200
• Hayward H-Series H200FD vs Raypak 156A
• Pentair MasterTemp 200 vs Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 200
• Hayward H-Series H200FD vs Pentair MasterTemp 200
• Hayward H-Series H200FD vs Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 200
• Hayward H-Series H150FD vs Raypak Digital 206A
• Pentair MasterTemp 125 vs Raypak 156A
• Hayward H-Series H150FD vs Raypak 156A
• Hayward H-Series H135FD vs Raypak 156A
• Raypak 106A vs Raypak 156A
• Hayward H-Series H150FD vs Hayward H-Series H200FD
• Hayward H-Series H150FD vs Pentair MasterTemp 125
• Hayward H-Series H135FD vs Pentair MasterTemp 125
• Hayward H-Series H135FD vs Hayward H-Series H150FD
• Pentair MasterTemp 125 vs Raypak 106A
• Hayward H-Series H150FD vs Raypak 106A
• Hayward H-Series H135FD vs Raypak 106A

Best Gas Pool Heaters for In-Ground Pools (250,000 BTU and Up)

• Raypak AVIA 404A vs Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 404A
• Pentair MasterTemp 400 vs Raypak AVIA 404A
• Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 404A vs Raypak Digital 406A
• Raypak AVIA 404A vs Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 400
• Pentair MasterTemp 400 vs Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 404A
• Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 404A vs Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 400
• Jandy JXiQ 400 with VersaFlo vs Raypak AVIA 404A
• Hayward H-Series H400FD vs Raypak AVIA 404A
• Raypak AVIA 404A vs Raypak Digital 336A
• Jandy JXi 400 vs Raypak AVIA 404A
• Pentair MasterTemp 400 vs Raypak Digital 406A
• Jandy JXiQ 400 with VersaFlo vs Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 404A
• Hayward H-Series H400FD vs Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 404A
• Raypak Digital 406A vs Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 400
• Jandy JXi 400 vs Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 404A
• Pentair MasterTemp 400 vs Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 400
• Jandy JXiQ 400 with VersaFlo vs Raypak Digital 406A
• Hayward H-Series H400FD vs Raypak Digital 406A
• Jandy JXi 400 vs Raypak Digital 406A
• Hayward H-Series H400FD vs Pentair MasterTemp 400
• Pentair MasterTemp 400 vs Raypak Digital 336A
• Hayward H-Series H400FD vs Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 400
• Raypak Digital 336A vs Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 400
• Jandy JXiQ 400 with VersaFlo vs Raypak Digital 336A
• Hayward H-Series H400FD vs Raypak Digital 336A
• Jandy JXi 400 vs Jandy JXiQ 400 with VersaFlo
• Jandy JXi 400 vs Raypak Digital 336A
• Hayward H-Series H400FD vs Raypak AVIA 264A
• Pentair MasterTemp 300 vs Pentair MasterTemp 400
• Hayward H-Series H400FD vs Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 264A
• Raypak AVIA 264A vs Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 264A
• Hayward H-Series H400FD vs Raypak Digital 266A
• Raypak Digital 266A vs Raypak Digital 336A
• Pentair MasterTemp 300 vs Raypak Digital 336A
• Pentair MasterTemp 300 vs Raypak AVIA 264A
• Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 264A vs Raypak Digital 266A
• Pentair MasterTemp 250 vs Raypak AVIA 264A
• Pentair MasterTemp 250 vs Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 264A
• Pentair MasterTemp 300 vs Raypak Digital 266A
• Hayward H-Series H250FD vs Raypak AVIA 264A
• Pentair MasterTemp 250 vs Raypak Digital 266A
• Jandy JXi 260 vs Raypak AVIA 264A
• Pentair MasterTemp 250 vs Pentair MasterTemp 300
• Hayward H-Series H250FD vs Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 264A
• Jandy JXi 260 vs Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 264A
• Hayward H-Series H250FD vs Raypak Digital 266A
• Jandy JXi 260 vs Raypak Digital 266A
• Hayward H-Series H250FD vs Pentair MasterTemp 250
• Jandy JXi 260 vs Pentair MasterTemp 250
• Hayward H-Series H250FD vs Jandy JXi 260

Across sizes

• Raypak AVIA 264A vs Raypak Digital 206A
• Raypak AVIA 264A vs Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 200
• Raypak AVIA HD NiTek 264A vs Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 200
• Pentair MasterTemp 250 vs Raypak Digital 206A
• Raypak Digital 266A vs Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 200
• Pentair MasterTemp 200 vs Pentair MasterTemp 250
• Pentair MasterTemp 250 vs Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm 200
• Hayward H-Series H200FD vs Pentair MasterTemp 250
• Hayward H-Series H200FD vs Hayward H-Series H250FD